TSP Mutual Fund Window: Managing Investment Options in MFW

While the standard TSP core funds provide a solid foundation, the Mutual Fund Window (MFW) allows for expanded investment options. This guide is a part of a 3-part series exploring the MFW. Part One explored the TSP window's origins and purpose, now we will learn how to effectively use it, focusing on cost considerations, strategic allocation, and avoiding common pitfalls to enhance your retirement savings.

Want to learn more about your TSP? Attend a Thrift Savings Plan webinar.

Introduction to the TSP Mutual Fund Window

The Mutual Fund Window is a feature within the TSP that allows TSP participants to invest in a wider list of mutual funds available beyond the standard TSP core funds. It is essentially a brokerage account within your TSP account, offering access to various mutual funds for greater investment diversification.

Who Can Benefit from the MFW?

The TSP Mutual Fund Window is ideally suited for experienced investors who have a significant TSP account balance and seek specific investment options not available in the TSP core. These TSP participants might want to invest in mutual funds that provide exposure to particular sectors or international markets, enhancing their overall investment allocation strategy. The FRTIB (Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board) suggests federal employees work with a fed-expert financial advisor before utilizing the available mutual funds in the window.

Costs Involved when You Invest Through the Mutual Fund Window

Before deciding to use the mutual fund window, it’s vital to grasp the associated fees and expenses. The MFW involves extra annual fees and trade fees, which can impact returns, especially with smaller account balances. Weigh these costs against the potential benefits of added diversification to decide if the MFW is right for your federal retirement. It is also important to check if there is a way to save for retirement outside of the TSP. Purchasing mutual fund shares in an IRA or private brokerage account can be more cost-effective in a lot of situations.

Cost Structure of the TSP Mutual Fund Window

One of the biggest criticisms of the MFW is that it can be expensive, especially if mismanaged. This is probably why less than 5% of federal employees and retirees have made use of the mutual fund window. Here is a break down of the expenses for mutual fund window users.

Annual and Per Trade Fees

The TSP Mutual Fund Window introduces additional fees on top of the standard TSP administrative expenses. These include annual fees ($95 for account maintenance, $37 for administrative costs) for maintaining the mutual fund window account and per-trade fees ($28.75 for each transaction), such as reallocations or fund transfers. These costs can quickly add up, reducing your overall returns on mutual funds within the MFW, especially if you overtrade.

Impact of Asset-Based Fees

Besides direct fees, the mutual funds themselves come with asset-based fees, known as expense ratios. These are deducted directly from the fund's assets and affect your investment returns. Higher expense ratios in the mutual funds available can create a compounding drag over time, especially compared to the low-cost TSP core funds like the G Fund. These fees range from fractions of a percent to as high as 3% of the amount invested depending on the individual mutual fund.

Investment Options within the Mutual Fund Window

The TSP core funds, G, F, C, S, and I, serve as a low-cost foundation for retirement savings within your TSP account. These funds offer broad diversification and low fees (expense ratios), making them ideal for the majority of your investment allocation. To gain access to the MFW, you must have a minimum TSP balance of $40,000 as you can only put in up to 25% of your balance and there is a requirement to invest $10,000 or more when initially transferring from Traditional and Roth balances.

When to Add Mutual Funds to Core TSP Funds

While the TSP core funds offer broad market exposure, there are situations where adding mutual funds through the mutual fund window may be beneficial. This includes seeking exposure to specific sectors, investment options, or international markets not fully represented in the core funds. For instance, you might want to invest in mutual funds focused on emerging markets or small-cap international stocks to complement your TSP core.

Strategies for Allocation

When using the mutual fund window, strategic asset allocation is key. It's generally best to keep the majority of your assets in the TSP core due to its low costs and broad diversification. Only allocate a smaller portion, perhaps 5-20%, to mutual funds through the mutual fund window account for targeted exposure. This helps maintain a balance between cost-effectiveness and diversification within your TSP savings. Therefore, having a substantial balance (more than the minimum $40,000) before considering purchasing some of the 5000 mutual funds in the window to broaden your investment choices.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls in the MFW

One of the biggest risks within the mutual fund window is overtrading. Each trade fee can erode returns, especially if you're frequently reallocating mutual funds based on short-term market fluctuations. The MFW should be viewed as a long-term investment, not a place for constant buying and selling.

Book a free consultation with a federal retirement expert to discuss your retirement savings plan strategy.

The Dangers of Over-Diversification

While diversification is important, over-diversification in the mutual fund window can lead to unnecessary complexity and higher fees and expenses. Holding too many mutual funds within the separate mutual fund window can result in overlapping holdings, diluting the benefits of diversification. It's better to focus on a few carefully selected mutual funds that serve specific purposes within your overall investment strategy.

Importance of Rebalancing

Rebalancing is crucial for maintaining your desired risk level and investment allocation in your TSP account. Over time, some investments may outperform others, causing your portfolio to drift away from its original targets. Regularly rebalancing your TSP funds, including any investments in mutual funds available through the window, helps ensure you stay aligned with your long-term financial goals and risk tolerance.

Practical Steps for Using the MFW Effectively

Before utilizing the TSP Mutual Fund Window, clearly define your investment goals. Are you seeking greater exposure to international markets, or do you want to invest in mutual funds with specific ESG criteria? Having well-defined goals will help you make informed decisions and select mutual funds that align with your overall investment allocation. This clarity ensures that your fund selections serve a specific purpose within your TSP account. Meet with a retirement plan fiduciary to determine whether the MFW makes sense for you.

Screening for the Best Mutual Funds

Screening mutual funds requires a careful approach, focusing on several key factors. Look for funds with low expense ratios to minimize costs and maximize returns within the mutual fund window. Prioritize funds with long track records and consistent investment strategies. Avoid niche, speculative, or overly complex funds that may introduce unnecessary risk to your TSP savings and carefully evaluate the annual fees involved. Participants who choose to invest in the window are taking on more risk in hopes of greater returns, not having a clear strategy can be detrimental to your future income in retirement.

Implementing Your Strategy

Implement your strategy with a measured approach once you've defined your goals and screened potential mutual funds. Make your initial allocation to mutual funds through the TSP Mutual Fund Window. Plan to rebalance only once or twice per year to maintain your desired asset allocation. Review your costs and performance annually to ensure your fund selections continue to align with your investment objectives within the TSP account and consider the trade fee associated with any changes to your fund allocation.

Use the Thrift Savings Plan calculator to estimate your future TSP growth.